Skip to content
0488 878 000
  • Custom Engagement Rings, Designed Around You
  • Certified Diamonds, Chosen With GIA Guidance
  • Book a Complimentary Private Consultation
  • Handmade in Melbourne, Shipped Australia-Wide
  • Family Jewellers Since 1984, 5-Star on Google
  1. Education
  2. Buying Knowledge & Custom Process
  3. Where to Buy Diamonds in Melbourne: 5 Sellers Compared Side by Side

Neutral guide, updated November 2026

Where to Buy Diamonds in Melbourne: 5 Sellers Compared Side by Side

Five Melbourne businesses that sell diamonds and diamond jewellery, listed in alphabetical order with what each one says about itself on its own website. No rankings and no opinions: where they are, what they sell, and a checklist for comparing diamonds between sellers.

Loose round brilliant diamond on gem paper beside a jeweller's loupe
Raj SoodReviewed by Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), AJP (GIA)Founder and Graduate Gemologist (GIA) · reviewed 17 November 2026Updated 17 November 20269 min read
Where to Buy Diamonds in Melbourne: 5 Sellers Compared Side by Side

Quick answer

Where to buy diamonds in Melbourne depends on whether you want natural or lab-grown, a loose stone or a finished ring, and whether you buy online or in person. Five sellers on this list are GemTrove, Hardy Brothers, Mazzucchelli's, Michael Hill and Tiffany & Co. GemTrove wrote this guide and is one of them.

5Melbourne diamond sellers, A to Z
0rankings or scores on this page
16 November 2026date each website was read
1of the five wrote this guide: GemTrove

Where can you buy diamonds in Melbourne?

In Melbourne you can buy a diamond as a loose stone, chosen on its own before the setting, or already set in a ring or a piece of jewellery. Sellers range from large jewellery stores with their own collections to showrooms that list every stone online with its grading report. The five below are established Melbourne diamond sellers with stores or showrooms. They are listed alphabetically, not ranked.

  • GemTrove (Melbourne CBD showroom, and online).
  • Hardy Brothers (338 Collins Street, Melbourne CBD).
  • Mazzucchelli's (Melbourne stores, including Highpoint; online).
  • Michael Hill (Bourke Street, Melbourne CBD, and other stores).
  • Tiffany & Co. (267 Collins Street, Melbourne CBD).

Declared interest: GemTrove wrote this guide and is one of the five on it. To keep it fair, every other entry uses only what that business says on its own website, we give no scores, and we say nothing about anyone's quality, prices or service.

How was this list put together?

  • Who is on it: established jewellers with Melbourne stores or showrooms that sell diamonds, chosen by GemTrove, plus GemTrove itself.
  • Where the facts come from: each business's own website, read on 16 and 17 November 2026. Nothing is taken from review sites, forums or advertising.
  • What is left out on purpose: review counts, star ratings, price comparisons and any judgement of quality. Those change often and are better checked at the source on the day you are deciding.
  • Order: alphabetical. Position on the page means nothing.
  • Updates: the page is re-read against each website about once a month, and the date at the top changes with it. If a detail about your business is out of date, tell us and it will be corrected.

What does each Melbourne diamond seller say about itself?

Each entry below is a plain summary of what the business's own website said on 16 and 17 November 2026. Follow the name to the source to check the current details.

Hardy Brothers (hardybrothers.com.au). Its website gives its Melbourne boutique as 338 Collins Street and lists engagement and wedding rings, dress rings, earrings, necklaces, pendants and bracelets, with Argyle pink diamonds in its range. Appointments can be booked.

Mazzucchelli's (mazzucchellis.com.au). Its website says it has traded since 1903. Its Melbourne stores, including Highpoint, sell diamond engagement rings and jewellery, with De Beers Forevermark among its collections, and its lab-grown diamond jewellery is described as IGI-certified. Appointments can be booked.

Michael Hill (michaelhill.com.au). Its website describes its Bourke Street store in the Melbourne CBD as having a floor for bridal and diamond jewellery, with jewellery and diamond specialists and appointments available. It also lists a LAB. collection set with laboratory-grown diamonds.

Tiffany & Co. (tiffany.com.au). Its website gives its Melbourne store as 267 Collins Street, with appointments. It sells diamond engagement rings and says its diamonds are cut in house and that its engagement diamonds come with a Tiffany Diamond Certificate.

GemTrove. GemTrove wrote this guide. Certified natural and lab-grown diamonds are listed online in separate catalogues, each stone with its own price and grading report. Stones can be viewed by appointment with Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), or sent by tracked Australia Post within Australia. Stones and prices are on our pages about loose diamonds in Melbourne and GIA diamonds in Melbourne.

Melbourne diamond sellers compared in one table

BusinessWhere (from its website)What its website offers
GemTroveMelbourne CBD showroom, and onlineNatural and lab-grown, each priced online
Hardy Brothers338 Collins Street, Melbourne CBDEngagement rings and diamond jewellery
Mazzucchelli'sMelbourne stores, including Highpoint; onlineDiamond rings and jewellery, natural and lab-grown
Michael Hill280-282 Bourke Street, Melbourne CBD, and other storesDiamond rings and jewellery; lab-grown range
Tiffany & Co.267 Collins Street, Melbourne CBDDiamond engagement rings and jewellery

The wording in the table is shortened from each website as read on 16 and 17 November 2026. It describes how each business presents itself, not how one compares with another.

Not sure which one is right?

Send us the stones you are looking at and our gemologist will tell you which to choose and why.

Ask a gemologist

How do you compare diamonds between sellers?

Two sellers can quote very different prices for diamonds that sound the same. These checks make the comparison fair, whoever you buy from.

What should you ask before buying a loose diamond?

  1. Is this stone natural or lab-grown, and which laboratory graded it? Ask for the report number and check it on the laboratory's own website.
  2. Is the stone here, or brought in to order? Many diamonds listed online are held by a supplier until someone asks to see them.
  3. Can I see this exact stone before I pay? In person or on video, with its measurements.
  4. Does the price include GST, and delivery? Ask for the total.
  5. What is your returns policy on a loose diamond? Get it in writing.
  6. Can you set it, or can I take it to my own jeweller? Either is normal; ask what each costs.

Our diamond buying guide goes through the whole process, and round brilliant diamonds and oval diamonds are the two shapes most people start with. Please check the lab report before you commit.

Where does GemTrove fit among Melbourne diamond sellers?

GemTrove lists certified diamonds online in separate natural and lab-grown catalogues, each stone with its own price, photo or video where available, and grading report. The stones below are in stock now.

Natural diamonds in stock today

See all 38,650 in stock →

In stock when checked on 17 Nov 2026, 9:30 pm. Each diamond’s own page shows its live price and availability. Please check the lab report before you commit.

You can buy a stone on its own or have it made into a ring: see custom engagement rings in Melbourne and lab-grown diamonds in Melbourne. Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), shows diamonds by appointment at Unit 903/125 Swanston St, Melbourne VIC 3000.

Free consultation

Talk to a gemologist

Compare stones in person or online with Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), AJP (GIA).

Book a consultation

See diamonds with prices

FAQ

Common questions

Where can you buy diamonds in Melbourne?

It depends on whether you want natural or lab-grown, a loose stone or a finished ring, and whether you prefer to buy online or in person. Sellers on this list include GemTrove, Hardy Brothers, Mazzucchelli's, Michael Hill and Tiffany & Co.

Can you buy loose diamonds in Melbourne?

Yes. Some businesses sell certified diamonds on their own, without a setting, while most large jewellery stores sell diamonds already set in rings and jewellery. Ask any seller whether a stone can be bought on its own, and for its grading report.

Should a loose diamond come with a certificate?

It should come with a grading report from an independent laboratory such as GIA or IGI. Check the report number on the laboratory's website and match it to the inscription on the stone.

Is it cheaper to buy a diamond online?

Not necessarily. Compare the same carat, colour, clarity, cut and laboratory, and make sure the price includes GST and delivery. Dated figures such as a price index help you judge a quote.

Is this list ranked?

No. The sellers are in alphabetical order and no scores are given. GemTrove wrote the guide and is on it, which is why every other entry uses only what that seller says on its own website.

How often is this guide updated?

About once a month. Each website is re-read and the date at the top of the page is changed. Review counts, ratings and prices are left out because they change too often to keep accurate.

Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), showing a client an engagement ring

Ask a gemologist

Not sure which diamond to choose?

Raj Sood is a Graduate Gemologist (GIA) who works alongside our master jewellers. Bring the stones you are considering, or send the reports, and he will tell you honestly which one is better and why.

Education

Explore every topic

Proudly Australian Made and OwnedVisit Us in Melbourne