Skip to content
0488 878 000
  • Custom Engagement Rings, Designed Around You
  • Certified Diamonds, Chosen With GIA Guidance
  • Book a Complimentary Private Consultation
  • Handmade in Melbourne, Shipped Australia-Wide
  • Family Jewellers Since 1984, 5-Star on Google
  1. Education
  2. Buying Knowledge & Custom Process
  3. Why Diamond Prices Differ Between Jewellers

Buying knowledge

Why Diamond Prices Differ Between Jewellers

Two jewellers can quote different prices for what sounds like the same diamond. Usually both are being straight with you. They run different kinds of business, and the two stones are less alike than the grades suggest.

Three polished gold bands in yellow, white and rose, slim to wide, showing how wedding band width varies on travertine
Raj SoodReviewed by Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), AJP (GIA)Founder and Graduate Gemologist (GIA) · reviewed 17 November 2026Updated 17 November 20269 min read
Why Diamond Prices Differ Between Jewellers

Quick answer

Diamond prices differ between jewellers for two reasons. First, the business: a chain of showrooms and a by-appointment jeweller carry different costs for rent, stock, staff and advertising. Second, the stone: two diamonds with the same grades are rarely identical. GemTrove, a by-appointment jeweller at Unit 903/125 Swanston St, Melbourne VIC 3000, wrote this guide and names no store and no prices in it.

Two reasonsthe business model, and the stone itself
Same gradesdo not mean the same diamond
No store namedand no prices quoted, on purpose
Compare like with likereport, measurements, metal, what is included

Who wrote this guide, and why does it name no one?

GemTrove wrote this guide. We are a by-appointment jeweller in Melbourne, so we are one of the two kinds of business it describes, and you should read it knowing that.

It names no store and quotes no prices, on purpose. A fair price comparison needs the same diamond, on the same day, with the same things included, and prices change daily. What does not change is why different kinds of jeweller arrive at different figures. That is what this guide explains, without saying that either kind is better.

What are you paying for when you buy a diamond ring?

The price on a ring is not the price of a diamond. It is the diamond plus everything it took to get that ring in front of you.

Part of the priceWhat it covers
The diamondWhat the jeweller paid for the stone
The settingPrecious metal, small stones, design and making
Running the businessRent, staff, stock, security, advertising
GST10%, included in Australian retail prices
MarginWhat the business keeps after its costs

The first two differ with the stone and the design. The third differs with the kind of business. For the stone, see what determines a diamond's value; for the metal, see how gold prices affect jewellery prices.

How does a showroom chain set its prices?

A showroom chain has many stores, usually in shopping centres and main streets, open long hours, with jewellery on display that you can try on and take home that day. Each of those things is a service to the customer, and each has a cost.

  • Shopfronts. Leases in busy retail locations, fitted out and secured.
  • Stock on display. Finished rings in every case, in many sizes and styles, paid for before they are sold.
  • Staff and hours. People on the floor in every store, including weekends and late nights.
  • Advertising. National campaigns that make the name familiar.
  • Convenience. Walk in without booking, compare many finished rings at once, and often arrange finance or lay-by.

These costs are spread across everything the chain sells. That is the trade a customer makes: more convenience and more to see in person, paid for through the price.

How does a by-appointment jeweller set its prices?

A by-appointment jeweller usually works from one upstairs office or workshop, sees customers by booking, and makes each ring to order. It holds little finished stock. Diamonds are chosen for each customer from listed inventory.

  • One location, not in a shopping centre, with no shopfront to fit out.
  • Little finished stock. The ring is made after you order it.
  • A small team. Often you deal with the jeweller or gemologist directly.
  • Less advertising. Most customers come by search or by word of mouth.

The lower running costs can show in the price. The trade the customer makes is different: you have to book, there are fewer finished rings to try on, and a made-to-order ring takes time. See custom vs ready-made engagement rings and buying online vs in store.

Have two quotes you cannot compare?

Send us both, with the report numbers, and our gemologist will tell you plainly where the two stones and the two rings differ.

Ask a gemologist

Showroom chain or by-appointment jeweller: what is the difference?

Showroom chainBy-appointment jeweller
WhereMany shopfrontsOne office or workshop
VisitingWalk in, long hoursBook a time
Rings to try onMany finished ringsSamples; yours is made to order
Choosing the diamondFrom stock on handFrom listed inventory
Taking it homeOften the same dayAfter it is made
Running costsHigher, spread over all salesLower

Neither is the right answer for everyone. Someone who wants to try on twenty rings on a Saturday and leave with one is well served by a showroom. Someone who wants to choose a particular stone and have a ring made around it is well served by a jeweller who works that way.

Are the two diamonds really the same?

Often not. Two diamonds described as the same carat, colour and clarity can differ in ways that change the price a great deal. Before deciding one jeweller is dearer than another, check these:

Our guide to why two diamonds with the same 4Cs can have different prices goes through each of these. Please check the lab report before you commit, wherever you buy.

What does "wholesale" mean when a jeweller says it?

Strictly, wholesale is one business selling to another. A jeweller selling a diamond to you is selling at retail, whatever the sign says. When a jeweller uses the word with the public, it usually means the business also supplies the trade, or that it prices closer to trade levels than a showroom does.

The word on its own tells you little. What matters is the figure for a particular stone, with its report, on the day. Under Australian Consumer Law, a business must not mislead you about price, including with comparisons to a "was" price or a "valued at" figure that was never real. Ask what any comparison is based on.

See wholesale diamonds in Melbourne for how GemTrove uses the term, and replacement value vs resale value for why a valuation figure is not a price.

How do you compare two quotes fairly?

  1. Get the report number for each diamond. Look both up on the laboratory's own website. See how to verify a GIA report number.
  2. Line up the reports. Laboratory, carat weight, colour, clarity, cut, polish, symmetry, fluorescence and measurements. See how to read a GIA diamond report.
  3. Look at the stones, or their videos. A report does not show how a diamond handles light. See how to compare two diamonds side by side.
  4. Match the setting. Same metal, same carat of gold, similar weight, same number and size of small stones.
  5. Check GST is included in both figures.
  6. List what else is included. Resizing, a valuation, delivery, cleaning and checks afterwards.
  7. Then compare the totals. If one is still lower, ask each jeweller why. A good one will tell you.

See what a diamond report does not tell you and questions to ask before ordering.

What does the price not tell you?

  • How well the ring is made. Two settings can look alike in a photo and differ in metal weight and finish.
  • What happens afterwards. Resizing, repairs and checks over the years.
  • How you were treated. Whether your questions were answered plainly.
  • What the diamond would sell for. See diamond resale value explained.
  • Whether you needed that grade. A lower price on a grade you cannot see is still money spent on nothing. See colour vs clarity.

A lower price is not a sign of a worse diamond, and a higher price is not a sign of a better one. The report, the stone and what is included tell you that.

Where can you see diamond prices before you visit anyone?

Any jeweller that lists its diamonds online with a price and a report number lets you do the comparison above from home. GemTrove lists every diamond in its catalogue with its own price, grading report and, for most, a video.

For dated figures by size, see the diamond price index, the diamond price guide and the lab-grown diamond price guide. For who sells diamonds in Melbourne, see places to buy diamonds in Melbourne and engagement ring jewellers in Melbourne. Buying while travelling is a different comparison again: see buying a diamond overseas vs in Australia.

  • GemTrove showroom: Unit 903/125 Swanston St, Melbourne VIC 3000 (Level 9), opposite Melbourne Town Hall, by appointment.
  • Hours: Monday to Friday 9:30 am to 5:30 pm, Saturday 11:30 am to 1:00 pm, Sunday closed.
  • Phone: 0488 878 000.
  • Book: book a consultation and bring any quote you want explained.

Free consultation

Talk to a gemologist

Compare stones in person or online with Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), AJP (GIA).

Book a consultation

FAQ

Common questions

Why are diamond prices different between jewellers?

For two reasons. Jewellers run different kinds of business with different costs for rent, stock, staff and advertising, and two diamonds with the same grades are rarely identical in cut, fluorescence, laboratory or exact weight.

Are wholesale diamonds lower priced?

The word alone does not tell you. A jeweller selling to the public is selling at retail. Compare the figure for a specific diamond, with its report number, against another specific diamond.

Is it better to buy from a chain store or an independent jeweller?

Neither is better for everyone. A showroom chain offers walk-in convenience and many finished rings to try on. A by-appointment jeweller makes to order with lower running costs. It depends on how you want to buy.

Why can the same grade of diamond cost more at one jeweller?

Either the stones differ in ways the headline grades do not show, or the businesses have different costs to cover. Usually it is some of both. See why the same 4Cs can have different prices.

How do I compare two diamond quotes?

Get the report number for each stone, line up the reports, look at the stones or their videos, match the setting and metal, check GST is included, and list what else each quote includes.

Do diamond prices in Australia include GST?

Retail prices in Australia include 10% GST. Check that any quote you are comparing does. Visitors can read the Tourist Refund Scheme on jewellery.

Is it rude to ask a jeweller why their price is different?

No. It is a fair question, and a jeweller who is confident in the price will explain it. Bring the other quote and the report number.

Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), showing a client an engagement ring

Ask a gemologist

Want a quote explained?

Raj Sood is a Graduate Gemologist (GIA). Bring any quote, from anyone, with its report number, and he will tell you honestly what the diamond is and what you would be paying for.

Education

Explore every topic

Proudly Australian Made and OwnedVisit Us in Melbourne